• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • blog
  • About
  • Book Publications
  • Other Reading
  • Social Wall
  • Back Pages
  • Contact Me
< Back

Jim Murphy’s ‘Clause Four’ Moment and ‘Putting Scotland First’

January 12, 2015

Jim Murphy’s ‘Clause Four’ Moment and ‘Putting Scotland First’

Gerry Hassan

Sunday Mail, January 11th 2015

Jim Murphy has to do some simple things right now – as well as some difficult ones. He has to get noticed, cause a noise and get up certain people’s noses.

Murphy faces some significant challenges. He has a short time span in which to make an impact on, and make a difference to, Labour’s electoral prospects for the May 7th UK general election – and how it is seen by the electorate.

Both are tough asks. Who was the last Scottish Labour leader who made his or her mark on Scotland? A whole host of figures have passed through the last decade – leaving barely a mark on the public consciousness.

Murphy knows all this, and that he desperately needs to kick against the state of Scottish politics post-referendum: an insurgent, popular SNP – and a Labour Party which is struggling to come to terms with how to oppose it.

This is the rationale of Murphy’s actions this week. Yesterday he presented a redrafted version of Scottish Labour’s constitution to the party executive which will be put to members at a one-day conference in March. The party has declared that it will aim to ‘put Scotland first’, while not ‘giving up solidarity with people across the UK’.

Earlier in the week Murphy promised 1,000 more nurses than the SNP. That’s right. Not a 1,000 more nurses, but a 1,000 more than any number that the SNP promise. That’s a seriously open-ended pledge.

Not only that, but Murphy linked this to Ed Miliband’s mansion tax on homes valued at over £2 million plus which are mostly based in London and the South East. Just in case this connection was missed, Scottish Labour tweeted from their official account that ‘95% will be levied in the South East of the UK.’

Murphy’s actions are high risk. The new ‘Clause Four’ moment attempts to revisit New Labour’s greatest success – when Blair established his moderate credentials by rewriting the party constitution twenty years ago. But that was a very different time. Then Labour was on the up. Now they are in retreat and scrambling to regain the political initiative.

The new intent have even been called by Labour ‘Murphy’s Law’. Yet, there is an admission in Murphy’s statements that not only has he and his party to prove their Scottish credentials, but by feeling they have to say they ‘put Scotland first’ they are conceding that at some point they did not do this.

The announcement on nurses met criticism from London Labour MPs such as Diane Abbott, David Lammy and Tessa Jowell. All of them, not without relevance, are positioning themselves for the next London Mayoral Labour candidature, and concerned about how Labour comes over with what are seen as ‘middle class voters’. This despite the fact that in the rest of the country £2 million plus homes would count as the super-rich.

This showed that very few members of the Westminster political class understand the Barnett formula: the 30 year plus calculation used to determine Scottish, as well as Welsh and Northern Irish public spending levels. The Barnett formula is about how English expenditure relates to Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland. The mansion tax isn’t expenditure, but revenue which leads to expenditure. Murphy seemed to not grasp this.

London Labour politicians have literally become city nationalists – defending their respective political constituencies. Territorial politics are beginning to matter as much, if not on some occasions more, than class and ideology.

Murphy has left a mark this week. He has created ripples across Britain. He has irritated some people. He has grabbed the headlines and exposed schisms. But he has to do a lot more.

So far he has enacted not a politics of strategy and substance, but one that is reactive and about the politics of the personal. His core appeal up to now seems to be ‘I am a big beast, trust me, I will stand up for Scotland and won’t be pushed around by Westminster’.

This is implicit in Murphy’s statement that ‘Scottish Labour is now under new leadership’. Aided by his new chief of staff John McTernan who is a former Blair adviser, the key ingredients in Labour’s offer will be leadership mixed with a populist, hard-edged appeal.

This puts a lot of weight upon Murphy’s shoulders. He is in effect offering a personal compact with voters – above and beyond everything else, including where real power sits in both party and country. This is the kind of presidential politics more suited to Westminster or the US than Scotland, but also a holding operation, and the most he can do in a short time.

Murphy knows he can craft some of his own personal appeal and agenda, but that changing the party and its appeal is a much longer project. All of this begs the question which Labour has avoided throughout devolution: can a party which has only a partial and limited autonomy really dare to put Scotland’s interests first? We are about to find out in the coming election.

 

 

 

 

Filed Under: Blog Tagged With: Jim Murphy, Scottish Labour Party, Scottish politics, Sunday Mail

Primary Sidebar

categories

  • Blog
  • Events
  • Futures Thinking
  • International Conversations
  • Longer Essays
  • Short Essays
  • What Gerry's groovin' to
  • What Gerry's reading
FacebookTwitter

featured publication

Scotland Rising: The Case for Independence

Click here to buy Gerry’s latest book.

what Gerry’s groovin’ to

My Musical Highlights of the Year

December 17, 2021

what Gerry’s reading

My Favourite Books of the Year 2021

December 15, 2021

tags

Scottish politics | Scottish Independence | Scottish Review | British politics | The Scotsman | Scottish Nationalists | Scottish Nationalism | Open Democracy | Nicola Sturgeon | Scottish Labour Party | Scottish society | Sunday National | The British State | Sunday Mail | Brexit | Boris Johnson | Social Democracy | Scottish National Party | Conservative Party | British Labour Party | Alex Salmond | Jeremy Corbyn | David Cameron | Popular Culture | The National | Scottish Parliament | Bella Caledonia | Scottish Media | Scottish Independence Referendum | British Conservatives | British Nationalism | Social Justice | Scottish Unionism | The Future of the Left | Scottish Men | 2021 Scottish Parliament elections | British Society | Scottish Culture | Football | CoronaVirus

Categories

Footer

about Gerry

Gerry Hassan is a writer, commentator and thinker about Scotland, the UK, politics and ideas.

More >

recent

  • How the 1970s began for me and how I was nearly written off at the age of five
  • Independence is not about process politics. It is about democracy
  • What Scotland’s big independence debate is about and should be about

search

FacebookTwitter

Terms of Use | Privacy Statement
Copyright © Gerry Hassan - writing, research, policy and ideas. All Rights Reserved.
Illustration and website design by Infinite Eye